THURSDAY, Dec. 9 (HealthDay News) -- The bone drug zoledronic
acid (Zometa), considered a potentially promising weapon against
breast cancer recurrence, has flopped in a new study involving more
than 3,360 patients.
Zometa did not appear to prevent breast cancer from returning or
to boost disease-free survival overall. British researchers
presented the disappointing findings Thursday at the San Antonio
Breast Cancer Symposium in Texas.
"As a whole, the study is negative," study author Dr. Robert Coleman, a professor of medical oncology at the University of Sheffield in England, said during a Thursday news conference on the findings. "There is no overall difference in recurrence rates or survival rates [between patients who got the bone drug and those who did not], except in older patients, defined as more than five years after menopause."
That was a possible bright spot in the results.
"In that population, there is a benefit," Coleman said. The older women had a 27 percent improvement in recurrence and a 29 percent improvement in overall survival over the five-year follow-up, compared to those who didn't get the drug.
"There was tremendous hope that this [drug] approach would be a major leap forward," Coleman noted. "There have been other trials that suggest this is the case." In one previous study, the use of the drug was linked with a 32 percent improvement in survival and lowered recurrence in younger women with breast cancer.
Other research has found that healthy women on bone drugs were
less prone to develop breast cancer, so experts were hoping the
drugs had an anti-tumor effect.
Zometa, marketed by Novartis AG, is used to relieve pain when
cancers have spread to the bone -- in part, by slowing bone erosion
caused by the disease. It is given intravenously, while other
bisphosphonates such as Actonel, Fosamax or Boniva can be taken
In the trial, known as AZURE (Adjuvant Treatment with Zoledronic
Acid in State II/III Breast Cancer), Coleman and his colleagues
evaluated 3,360 breast cancer patients from 174 participating
centers, all with stage II or III cancers but no evidence of
metastases (cancer that has spread beyond the original site). About
half received the bone drugs plus standard therapy; half just got
The focus was on disease-free survival. After five years, about
400 women in each group either died or had recurrences.
When Coleman's team looked at subgroups, however, they found the
benefit among older women, a finding they say warrants more
"The younger patients are getting no benefit," Coleman said. "If anything, they are doing a little bit worse."
In addition, there were some troubling side effects among women
taking Zometa, including 17 cases of osteonecrosis of the jaw (a
severe bone disease that can result in death of the jawbone).
Dr. Sharon Giordano, an associate professor of breast medical
oncology at the University of Texas M.D. Anderson Cancer Center,
was not involved in the study but put it in perspective.
Bisphosphonates have been used to treat osteoporosis as well as
bone complications of breast cancer treatment, she said.
"The role of bisphosphonates in preventing cancer recurrence has been less clear," she said, noting that multiple studies have had conflicting findings.
As for the benefit found in postmenopausal women, she said, "I
would consider this hypothesis-generating and not
Other studies underway may provide a clearer answer, she
Since the current study was presented at a meeting, its findings
should be considered preliminary until published in a peer-reviewed
Said Coleman: "Zoledronic acid cannot be routinely recommended
for prevention of cancer returning, but it remains a very good drug
for patients where the cancer has already spread to the bone."
Coleman disclosed receiving speaker fees from Novartis; the
researchers also received academic grant funding from the drug
For more information on bisphosphonates, visit
U.S. Food and Drug Administration.