WEDNESDAY, Jan. 12 (HealthDay News) -- Amid the ongoing
controversy over routine antibiotic use for children with acute ear
infections, two new studies support the practice when stringent
diagnostic criteria are met.
Researchers from Children's Hospital of Pittsburgh and the
University of Turku in Finland found antibiotics more effective
than a placebo in reducing ear infection severity and duration in
toddlers. In both studies, the rate of clinical failure -- defined
as persistent signs of acute infection -- was dramatically lower
days later among those prescribed amoxicillin-clavulanate
(Augmentin) than in children left untreated.
Acute ear infection, known medically as otitis media, is the
most frequent bacterial illness diagnosed during early childhood
and the most common reason antibiotics are prescribed for children
in the United States, according to prior research.
"The study underscores the need to restrict antibiotic treatment to those with certain infection," said Dr. Alejandro Hoberman, a pediatrician at Children's Hospital of Pittsburgh and lead author of one of the studies. "I would say the really important point to understand is that the key to optimal management of acute otitis media is an accurate diagnosis. I do hope our findings . . . will settle the topic."
Hoberman and Dr. Jerome Klein, a professor of pediatrics at
Boston University School of Medicine, said a rash of research in
recent decades from Western Europe triggered debate over the
necessity of antibiotics by suggesting they initially be withheld
from children with ear infections as part of a watchful waiting
That approach, along with widespread fear over the increasing
emergence of antibiotic-resistant bacteria, has fueled the
treatment controversy, they said. However, the European studies
typically didn't enforce strict criteria for diagnosing ear
infections, whose symptoms can resemble upper respiratory
"What it boils down to is that a lot of uncertainty in prior investigations was because the diagnosis was not always as secure as these two papers, where they've really been very careful," said Klein, who wrote an editorial supporting the results of both studies, reported in the Jan. 13 issue of the New England Journal of Medicine.
"A more casual approach to treatment muddied the waters" over antibiotic use in prior studies, Klein added, noting that he didn't expect the debate to die despite the latest findings.
In the Pittsburgh study, 291 children between the ages of 6
months and 23 months old with certain ear infections -- as defined
by the presence of a bulging eardrum and parental observations,
among other symptoms -- were split into groups receiving
antibiotics or placebos for 10 days.
Among those who received amoxicillin-clavulanate, 35 percent had
initial resolution of symptoms by day two; 61 percent by day four;
and 80 percent by day seven. In contrast, of those on placebo, 28
percent had initial resolution of symptoms by day two, 54 percent
by day four and 74 percent by day seven.
But the rate of clinical failure for those on antibiotics after
day four or five was only 4 percent, vs. 23 percent for those on
placebo, the study found.
The Finnish research looked at 319 children between the ages of
6 months and 35 months for seven days, finding that treatment
failure occurred by the end of the study period in 18.6 percent of
children who received amoxicillin, compared to 44.9 percent of
those on placebo.
More research is needed to help doctors identify the children
who will benefit most from treatment, the authors said. Such
studies could reduce unnecessary use of antibiotics and the
potential for antibiotic resistance, they said.
"I thought [the Pittsburgh research] was a very good study," said Dr. Tumaini Coker, an assistant professor of pediatrics at the Mattel Children's Hospital and the David Geffen School of Medicine at the University of California, Los Angeles. "I think it's very interesting and useful. But like any research study, we need further studies that reinforce those findings."
Dr. Henry Bernstein, chief of general pediatrics at the Cohen
Children's Medical Center of New York, agreed that the two studies
will help resolve the controversy over how to treat children's ear
"Most importantly, the diagnosis of acute otitis media was well-defined and meticulously made by experienced physicians at enrollment," Bernstein said.
To learn more about children's ear infections, visit the
American Academy of Family Physicians.