WEDNESDAY, June 1 (HealthDay News) -- People who become very
afraid of dying in the moments during and days after a heart attack
also seem to have more inflammation, an indicator that they may, in
the long run, do worse than patients who are less fearful, a small
British study suggests.
The finding, published online June 1 in the
European Heart Journal, "reminds us of the connection between the mind and the body," said Dr. Suzanne Steinbaum, a preventive cardiologist with Lenox Hill Hospital in New York City.
"This trial shows us that when patients are so fearful, there's an increase in inflammation and decrease in heartbeat variability, which could lead to poor outcomes. So we must address not only the body issues but the mind issues as well," she said.
Added Dr. Robert Gramling, associate professor of family
medicine at the University of Rochester Medical Center in New York:
"This and the vast literature related to emotions and mind/body
interactions are confirmatory that understanding people's emotional
response does interplay with the biologic mechanisms. I believe,
yes, attending to emotions is extraordinarily important, not only
for the well-being of the individual's emotional and mental health
but also for physical health and maybe even evolution of myocardial
infarction [a heart attack]."
For the new study, researchers assessed 208 patients who had
come to St. George's Hospital in London with acute coronary
syndrome -- blockage of the coronary arteries -- during an 18-month
time frame. They were asked during their hospital stay about their
fear of dying. At the same time, the researchers also measured
blood levels of tumor necrosis factor (TNF), which is involved in
triggering inflammation.
Three weeks later, the researchers visited patients in their
homes and measured heart rate variability and levels of the stress
hormone cortisol in the saliva.
One in five patients reported feeling extreme distress and fear
of dying, while two-thirds experienced more moderate emotional
reactions. People who were younger, poorer and unmarried (possibly
indicating social isolation) were more likely to have intense
reactions, the study found.
Fear of dying was associated with a fourfold increase in TNF
levels at time of admission to the hospital. Three weeks later, TNF
levels were found to be linked with lower heart rate variability
and lower cortisol levels.
Lower heart rate variability levels have been linked with higher
death rates after a heart attack, while lower cortisol levels may
indicate that the body isn't able to quell the inflammation caused
by a heart attack.
To the researchers' surprise, having had a previous heart attack
didn't influence how scared the patients were.
The study does have some limitations, including the fact that
some 23 percent of the patients dropped out after three weeks;
there were few women; and most patients had STEMI (ST-elevation
myocardial infarction), the more severe type of heart attack,
meaning that the findings can't really be extrapolated to non-STEMI
heart attacks.
"It's a very small study, it's predominantly those with STEMI heart attacks and, most of the patients, we don't know all the clinical information," said Dr. Stephen Green, associate chairman of cardiology at North Shore University Hospital in Manhasset, N.Y.
Nor does the study answer the "chicken-and-egg" question of
whether emotional distress caused the biological findings or vice
versa.
"The study provokes a lot of thoughts in terms of what physicians should do with patients and what patients should do for themselves and [directions for] future research. [But] it's just a beginning in my mind and something that we shouldn't translate into changing our practices at this point," Green said.
More information
The American Heart Association has more on
acute coronary syndrome.