THURSDAY, July 14 (HealthDay News) -- A coalition of the
nation's largest food makers on Thursday unveiled a plan to set new
nutrition standards for foods that can be advertised to
children.
The standards include reducing sugar, salt, calories and trans
fat and saturated fat.
But, they still fall short of recommendations proposed by the
Obama administration in April.
"We have established uniform criteria for participating companies' child-directed advertising," Elaine Kolish, vice president and director of the Children's Food and Beverage Advertising Initiative, which includes such companies as ConAgra, General Mills and Kellogg, said during a Thursday morning press conference.
"These new criteria are challenging, but realistic, goals for further improving the products advertised to children," she said.
According to Kolish, about one-third of products currently
advertised to kids don't meet the new nutrition criteria. By Dec.
31, 2013, products must meet the new standards or they can't be
advertised to kids.
The standards affect foods in the following categories: dairy;
grains; fruits and vegetables; soups and meal sauces; seeds; nuts,
nut butters and spreads; meat, fish and poultry; mixed dishes; and
prepared main dishes and meals, such as macaroni and cheese. Each
category has its own criteria, Kolish said.
For example, juices can't have added sugars and no more than 160
calories per serving. For flavored milk, an 8-ounce serving will be
limited to 24 grams of sugar. Cereals with about 150 calories per
serving can have no more than 1.5 grams of saturated fat, 290
milligrams of salt and 10 grams of sugar.
Also, peanut butter can have no more than 220 calories per 2
tablespoons, 3.5 grams of saturated fat, 240 milligrams of salt and
4 grams of sugar.
The criteria also call for specified amounts of fruits,
vegetables, low or non-fat dairy, whole grains and some products to
be supplemented with calcium and vitamin D, Kolish said.
Eric Decker, chairman of the Department of Food Science at the
University of Massachusetts, was asked by Kolish to review the new
standards. Speaking at the news conference, he said, "These
guidelines are a tremendous step forward, because they provide a
balance for the nutritional significance of the food and yet allow
inclusions of foods that are going to taste good and be
affordable."
In April, the U.S. government issued guidelines it said it hopes
the food industry will adopt for lower amounts of sugar, salt and
fats in foods advertised to children. Those guidelines are lower
than the new industry guidelines.
Kolish said she hopes the government will modify its guidelines,
which she called unrealistic and unattainable.
"We share the same goals as these government agencies. We all want healthier kids," she said. "But we think the government's proposal is unworkable and unrealistic."
For instance, Kolish said, to reduce salt levels by more than
half "one would have to overcome vast technical issues, and then
you would have to have a product consumers would actually eat."
Obesity expert Dr. David L. Katz, director of the Prevention
Research Center at Yale University School of Medicine, said "the
food industry is acknowledging that advertising foods of
questionable nutritional value to children in an age of epidemic
childhood obesity and diabetes is wrong. That is certainly a good
thing."
But, there's an inescapable conflict of interest when the
companies that profit from selling foods decide how to limit their
own marketing, Katz said. "No one with a modicum of real-world
common sense is surprised that the home-grown standards of food
companies are less restrictive than the government standards the
same companies rejected," he noted.
"The right approach, which the industry does not even seem to be considering, would be to link marketing to a reliable measure of overall nutritional quality, not just a select nutrient or two. One-nutrient-at-a-time guidance can be entirely misleading," Katz added.
An estimated one-third of U.S. children are now considered
overweight or obese. Kids who are too heavy run the risk of high
blood pressure and high cholesterol; type 2 diabetes; breathing
problems, such as sleep apnea, and asthma; joint problems; fatty
liver disease; and social and psychological problems, such as
discrimination and poor self-esteem, which can continue into
adulthood, according to the National Institutes of Health.
More information
To learn more about healthy eating for kids, visit the
Nemours Foundation.